Amazon’s Alexa+, the generative AI-powered upgrade to its long-running voice assistant, is failing at basic tasks that its predecessor handled without issue, according to extended real-world testing on the Echo Show 15.
The revamped assistant launched in 2025 with Amazon positioning it as a smarter, more conversational replacement for the original Alexa. It is available to all Amazon Prime subscribers in the United States, and Echo device owners are automatically switched over to the new version. The company rebuilt Alexa around a generative AI core, promising better intent recognition, more natural conversation, and the ability to manage multi-step tasks like ordering groceries or booking an Uber.
In practice, the assistant struggles with requests that are far less complex.
Music Requests That Miss the Mark
Asking Alexa+ to play music on YouTube has become unreliable to the point of comedy. A request for Charli XCX returned a track by Sombr called “Back to Friends.” Asking for The Black Keys produced Alabama Shakes. When it does not serve up a loosely related artist, the assistant sometimes drops a raw YouTube search on screen and waits for the user to make a manual selection.
Precise, rigid prompts occasionally worked. Phrasing a request as “Play the song ‘Best Guess’ by artist Lucy Dacus on YouTube” produced the correct result. But a simpler instruction, “Play a song by Lucy Dacus,” returned a literal YouTube search for that exact phrase. Rephrasing to “I want to hear a Lucy Dacus song” triggered a glitch that skipped the search entirely and returned to the home screen.
That outcome sits awkwardly against Amazon’s own pitch: that generative AI understands underlying intent, not just literal commands.
Video Playback Failures
Navigation across streaming apps produced similar friction. Asking Alexa+ to play a teaser clip for an upcoming episode of RuPaul’s Drag Race on YouTube was initially rejected as an unsupported action, with the assistant defaulting to “related content” instead. Multiple rephrasing attempts were required before it located the right clip.
Attempting to launch content through HBO Max exposed a more serious reliability issue. After Alexa+ displayed a recommendation for The Pitt on the home screen, repeated voice requests could only open the app’s “Who’s Watching” profile selection page. When asked directly whether it had played an episode, the assistant stated it was playing content when nothing was on screen, then suggested the show was simply paused. Asking it to resume playback caused it to replay a nature sounds session from earlier in the day.
Still Labeled “Early Access”
Amazon has not set a public timeline for when Alexa+ exits its early access period. Users can currently revert to the original Alexa by asking to “exit Alexa+,” though how long that option persists is not confirmed.
The problems documented here are not edge cases. They emerged from routine, everyday use: playing a specific song, queuing a video clip, launching a streaming show. These are requests the original Alexa handled with rigid but predictable reliability. The generative upgrade, designed to make those interactions feel more natural, currently makes them less dependable.
Amazon built Alexa+ to handle more ambitious tasks. At the moment, it is not reliably handling the straightforward ones.
Photo by Anete Lusina on Pexels
This article is a curated summary based on third-party sources. Source: Read the original article
